Eyeshadow Pencils

Shop by Category

Eyes

123 Results

Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon EGGPLANT ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIPPING
$12.90
or Best Offer
$4.80 shipping
3+^ C&* E]N w.?4!|/3 $BS p o n s o r e d
Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon AQUAMARINE ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIPPING
$14.90
or Best Offer
$4.80 shipping
DI+ ^C &O 52* ] GwB. ?J!|O / $S p o n s o r e d
CS Shiseido/Essentialist Eye Palette 04 Kaigan Street Waters 0.18 Oz (5.2 Ml)
(1)
$11.99
Free shipping
NF +^ &* MZ] 9 w1.?!| /A 3 $S p o n s o r e d
Shiseido Essentialist Eye Palette 0.18oz/5.2g New With Box
(1)
$16.99
Was: $34.00was - US $34.00
Free shipping
+W^ &R M5* 4]H w .?9!|Z/ $ S p o n s o r e d
Avon True Color Glimmersticks Brow Definer Set of 3 PICK YOUR SHADE DISCONTINUED
(8)
$24.99 to $36.99
Free shipping
ZM+^ E &* K] wE.P ?!X|/ $S
AVON Smooth Minerals Eye Pencil Crayon Eyeshadow .05 oz LIMESTONE ~ New Sealed
$15.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+X^U 1&*1 ] W2 Zw3 .?!6|/K $
Avon Eye Brightening Pencil LAVENDER BLUE Shadow & Liner NOS Like Big Color
$18.95
Free shipping
4 watching
Y+^ E &5F* ] A 3w. Q?8!|/ S$
Shiseido Brow InkTrio 02 Taupe 0.002oz Brand NEW In Original Box
$19.85
Free shipping
BZ 7+^ M O2 &* 81] w.?! 2X|/ $
new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - celadon
$28.99
Free shipping
T+K XO A1^ &E*N ] w.?3K!| / $
Shiseido Essentialist Eye Palette - 04 KAIGAN STREET WATERS - New & Boxed
(1)
$18.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+90 UD ^ &Y* ]C w.08 ?AY!| / $
SHISEIDO Essentialist Eye Palette 0.18 fl oz NEW IN BOX PICK YOUR SHADE
(1)
$21.24 to $25.49
Was: $24.99was - US $24.99
Free shipping
+^JM &* ] w.? O!7 |/ DC $WO
Shiseido / Essentialist Eye Palette 04 Kaigan Street Waters 0.18 oz (5.2 ml)
(1)
$16.49
Was: $34.00was - US $34.00
Free shipping
+^QI &K4 *6 ]I 7 9w. ?O!P| / $
new AVON Big Color Dazzlers Sparkling Eye Pencil - Cream
$12.45
Free shipping
OA +^ L&F* 6W ] 7wI.? !2|/ $
Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon VANILLA ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIPPING
$14.90
or Best Offer
$4.80 shipping
+^ &* 2J ]5 E w42 .?!|/5 P$S p o n s o r e d
Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon LAVENDER MIST ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIP
$14.90
or Best Offer
$4.80 shipping
+^ &* R]N w. LR?!|/ 5J N$U S p o n s o r e d
Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon PERFECT PEACH ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIP
$12.90
or Best Offer
$4.80 shipping
6F 80+^ & *B3 ] wZ.C ?!|/ $S p o n s o r e d
new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - nutmeg
$22.95
Free shipping
+^ ET& D* ] A QR Bw.?!M R|/3 $
New Sealed Avon Big Color Dual Ended Eye Pencil / Crayon Go To Greens .12 oz
$12.89
or Best Offer
Free shipping
M+B ^ &2C* ] w TA. EX ?!A|W/ $
new AVON oval options Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - golden eye
$11.97
Free shipping
+F^ C&* ]06 w.HU? !|/0 A$
AVON Extra lasting Eye Shadow ~ Blue Meridian !! 2 EYESHADOW !! DISCONTINUED
$12.99
Free shipping
+^U &*N VJ NE ] Cw.?!|/O $
AVON Eye Pencil "Big Color"Smooth Minerals"Wrapped in Cashmere" (J1)
$12.99
$5.40 shipping
B+^C &* ] LwL.? !|/F T$
New Sealed Avon Big Color Dual Ended Eye Pencil / Crayon Silver Smoke .12 oz
$12.89
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+^ 1V&* ] w.?!|H/ P W7 Z0 6$
AVON EXTRALASTING EYESHADOW PENCIL NEW
$4.99
$4.00 shipping
G+^ &B* G]Z w. 1?!|/B WD$
AVON Glimmer Shadow *ROSE GOLD* + AVON Big Color **LIGHTENING** Eye Pencil Set
(3)
$18.00
$3.50 shipping
+^P 8&* ] UU wWA.?! |U/ N $
new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon eyeshadow eye liner - silver bullet
$22.95
Free shipping
56+^ &V* ]6 wH.?!|3/ OT $
AVON Eyeliner Big Color Eye Pencil Crayon Liner Eyeshadow SUNNY PINK Sealed!
$18.88
Free shipping
+C^ T& * ] Cw.?!O |/ ZX$ 2
Avon Glow 2 in 1 Eye Pencil Metallic Sands
$14.88
Free shipping
+^1 D &* ]6G 9Mw.?! |/Z $E
Avon Eye Brightening Pencil, New & Factory Sealed, Lavender Blue
$13.96
Free shipping
+^ 0&* Y] wDV. ?4C !|7/O N$
Avon Smooth Minerals Eyeshadow
$11.99 to $12.79
Was: $15.99was - US $15.99
$4.88 shipping
+^ &* ] 8wU 0.?!Z|/ 3$B DS p o n s o r e d
new Avon Glow 2 in 1 eye pencil crayon eye liner eyeshadow - Beach Beauty P907
$13.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+UZ^ & FE * N1] 1w.?!V |/S $S p o n s o r e d
Avon Lip Color BIG Color Glossy Lip Pencil GLOSSY SUNSET New NOS Sealed!
$18.88
$5.00 shipping
+^J H &N* ]F wL7 .?DP MA!|/ $S p o n s o r e d
new Avon Extra Lasting eyeshadow pencil - shimmering sand K50
$13.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+39^ & 3* ]E Q7 w.?W!0| / $S p o n s o r e d
Avon Eye Brightening Pencil eyeshadow - frosting
$20.00
Free shipping
Only 1 left!
+^ &U* 6 4] Ow 2O.?! |/D 2 R$
Two (2) new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - eggplant SEALED
$28.00
$5.24 shipping
P5+ ^ F&A* ] wP.?Y X!|X/ $
Avon Eye Brightening Pencil HONEY BLUE Shadow & Liner NOS Like Big Color retired
$19.99
or Best Offer
$4.50 shipping
8+4^ &R5* ] W Hw.?! 6|/ $
SHISEIDO ESSENTIALIST EYE PALETTE 04 KAIGAN STREET WATERS 0.18 OZ (5.2 ML)
(1)
$19.95
Free shipping
+Y^ &4 *Y ]P w.?J!F 8T |DD/ $
AVON CATHY CATS SHADOW GAZE COLOR STICK:FREE SHIPPING
$12.25
or Best Offer
Free shipping
T+^X &* ] KwR. 5?M !HV|/ $
new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - cocoa praline
$21.90
Free shipping
YG C+V ^ &*2M ] wH.C?! Z|/T $
Shiseido Essentialist Eye Palette Size 5.2 g / 0.18 oz New In Box Choose Yours!
(1)
$29.79
Free shipping
+L^ &* N] w J8 .JL ?L!2|/ P$S p o n s o r e d
CS Shiseido/Essentialist Eye Palette (03 Namiki Street Nature) 0.18 Oz (5.2 Ml)
$60.35
Free shipping
M+^ &K* 7S ]2 w2. ?XR J!1| / $S p o n s o r e d
new Avon Glow 2 in 1 eye pencil crayon eye liner eyeshadow - beach beauty
$15.97
Free shipping
Z9+^ 4&*E O ]M L Yw Q.?M! |/ $
New Sealed Avon Color Dazzlers Sparkling Eye Pencil Lilac
$12.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+24^ 3J& *4E ] w6.V B?!V|/ $
new AVON Wrapped in Cashmere eyeshadow pencil - Coral Cashmere
$13.99
Free shipping
+PV^ &*F Q ]A wX. ?!E|/N 1$
new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - sunny pink
$11.97
Free shipping
0+^ &* ]F 1 J Lw.?M !E|0/ $
AVON Powderstix Eyeshadow Powder Pencil SILVER PLUM .06 oz pencil NEW sealed
$29.99
Free shipping
+^Z &C* ]YN Lw.?!|/K H $6
Avon Big Color Dual Ended eye pencil crayon eyeshadow liner - perfect nudes
$8.95
Free shipping
+62^ 11 &Q1* ] Lw.Z?! |/ $
Lot of AVON Eye Makeup Liners, Cream Eyeshadow and Eyeshadow Primer
$17.95
Free shipping
+^ &* RQ] w .BN? !YM|/ I$
AVON Sparkle Eyeshadow Stick - LATTE
$13.70
Free shipping
+HF^ &* ] D9 w .?5!K|/ 1$K
AVON Big Color Eye Pencil Crayon Liner Eyeshadow SUNKISSED New Sealed!
$19.00
Free shipping
H9+ ^H &* M] 9w7.? B!|/ $
Avon Sparkle Eyeshadow Stick pencil - Champagne
$8.95
Free shipping
S2+^ 9 I 5&*4 ] w.? !|/S D$
AVON Smooth Minerals Eye Shadow Pencil PEBBLE (HARD TO FIND) Sealed Eyeshadow
$19.99
Free shipping
3 watching
+1^B S &*6 0]Z OG w.N?!C|/ $
Avon Color Whirls 1988 Eye Pencil Violet Swirls
$5.00
$4.08 shipping
TG+^ &* Z]I w .?L2 FF! |VD/ $
AVON Sparkle Eyeshadow Stick - LATTE
$13.70
Free shipping
+^UI 9 Z&* ] 2w.?G!|/ 6 $Z
AVON Glimmer Shadow Liquid Eyeshadow - Crystal Lilac ~ New
(3)
$9.99
or Best Offer
$5.50 shipping
DS+^ &* H] 5 w.FR T?V !|4/ $
new Avon Extra Lasting eyeshadow pencil - crystal taupe K201
$24.97
Free shipping
0+^ &*W ]U6 w.?4B !|/1J $
AVON SMOOTH MINERALS EYE SHADOW PENCIL... LIMESTONE ....SEALED
$16.99
Free shipping
5+^ &7 9*A ] I 0w.? !CY|/ $
new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon eyeshadow eye liner - lightening B01
$19.97
Free shipping
+^74 &* J] w.?!|D /0A $
Avon Eye Brightening Pencil HONEY BLUE Shadow & Liner NOS Like Big Color
$17.95
Free shipping
+3^ W&* MZ ] w.?!|/ $FR
CS Shiseido/Essentialist Eye Palette 04 Kaigan Street Waters 0.18 Oz (5.2 Ml)
(1)
$15.99
Free shipping
J8+ D^ &* ] E wOV .CC?!| /M $S p o n s o r e d
Avon Big Color Dazzlers Sparkling Eye Pencil Cocoa Mauve
$19.99
or Best Offer
$4.50 shipping
UA+ ^ Q&S 6* ] w.Z ?!J|N /2 $S p o n s o r e d

Top Rated

See All

A349e Glinda Shadow Palettes Urban Decay Oz The Great and Powerful Eye Palette 604214642706
(13)

100% agree - Would recommend
$59.00 New
Julep Creme to Powder Eyeshadow Stick 101 Stone 0.04oz
(10)

100% agree - Would recommend
$16.99 New
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow - Cocoa
(7)

100% agree - Would recommend
$22.99 New
It Cosmetics Superhero No Tug Shadow Stick - Silk Armor Product
(6)

100% agree - Would recommend
$17.99 New
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24h Concentrated Crayon - Gold Rush
(6)

100% agree - Would recommend
$8.50 New
Clinique Shadow Tint Chubby Single Stick - 0.1 fl oz
(10)

87% agree - Would recommend
$19.50 New

Brand

Type

Motors

Clothing & Accessories

Sporting goods

Electronics

Business & Industrial

Jewelry & Watches

Collectibles & Art

Home & garden

Other categories

Eyeshadow Pencils

Shop by Category

123 Results

Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon EGGPLANT ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIPPING

Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon AQUAMARINE ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIPPING

CS Shiseido/Essentialist Eye Palette 04 Kaigan Street Waters 0.18 Oz (5.2 Ml)

Shiseido Essentialist Eye Palette 0.18oz/5.2g New With Box

Avon True Color Glimmersticks Brow Definer Set of 3 PICK YOUR SHADE DISCONTINUED

AVON Smooth Minerals Eye Pencil Crayon Eyeshadow .05 oz LIMESTONE ~ New Sealed

Avon Eye Brightening Pencil LAVENDER BLUE Shadow & Liner NOS Like Big Color

Shiseido Brow InkTrio 02 Taupe 0.002oz Brand NEW In Original Box

new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - celadon

Shiseido Essentialist Eye Palette - 04 KAIGAN STREET WATERS - New & Boxed

SHISEIDO Essentialist Eye Palette 0.18 fl oz NEW IN BOX PICK YOUR SHADE

Shiseido / Essentialist Eye Palette 04 Kaigan Street Waters 0.18 oz (5.2 ml)

new AVON Big Color Dazzlers Sparkling Eye Pencil - Cream

Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon VANILLA ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIPPING

Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon LAVENDER MIST ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIP

Avon Big Color Eyeshadow Pencil/Crayon PERFECT PEACH ~ SEALED ~ NEXT DAY SHIP

new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - nutmeg

New Sealed Avon Big Color Dual Ended Eye Pencil / Crayon Go To Greens .12 oz

new AVON oval options Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - golden eye

AVON Extra lasting Eye Shadow ~ Blue Meridian !! 2 EYESHADOW !! DISCONTINUED

AVON Eye Pencil "Big Color"Smooth Minerals"Wrapped in Cashmere" (J1)

New Sealed Avon Big Color Dual Ended Eye Pencil / Crayon Silver Smoke .12 oz

AVON EXTRALASTING EYESHADOW PENCIL NEW

AVON Glimmer Shadow *ROSE GOLD* + AVON Big Color **LIGHTENING** Eye Pencil Set

new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon eyeshadow eye liner - silver bullet

AVON Eyeliner Big Color Eye Pencil Crayon Liner Eyeshadow SUNNY PINK Sealed!

Avon Glow 2 in 1 Eye Pencil Metallic Sands

Avon Eye Brightening Pencil, New & Factory Sealed, Lavender Blue

Avon Smooth Minerals Eyeshadow

new Avon Glow 2 in 1 eye pencil crayon eye liner eyeshadow - Beach Beauty P907

Avon Lip Color BIG Color Glossy Lip Pencil GLOSSY SUNSET New NOS Sealed!

new Avon Extra Lasting eyeshadow pencil - shimmering sand K50

Avon Eye Brightening Pencil eyeshadow - frosting

Two (2) new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - eggplant SEALED

Avon Eye Brightening Pencil HONEY BLUE Shadow & Liner NOS Like Big Color retired

SHISEIDO ESSENTIALIST EYE PALETTE 04 KAIGAN STREET WATERS 0.18 OZ (5.2 ML)

AVON CATHY CATS SHADOW GAZE COLOR STICK:FREE SHIPPING

new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - cocoa praline

Shiseido Essentialist Eye Palette Size 5.2 g / 0.18 oz New In Box Choose Yours!

CS Shiseido/Essentialist Eye Palette (03 Namiki Street Nature) 0.18 Oz (5.2 Ml)

new Avon Glow 2 in 1 eye pencil crayon eye liner eyeshadow - beach beauty

New Sealed Avon Color Dazzlers Sparkling Eye Pencil Lilac

new AVON Wrapped in Cashmere eyeshadow pencil - Coral Cashmere

new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - sunny pink

AVON Powderstix Eyeshadow Powder Pencil SILVER PLUM .06 oz pencil NEW sealed

Avon Big Color Dual Ended eye pencil crayon eyeshadow liner - perfect nudes

Lot of AVON Eye Makeup Liners, Cream Eyeshadow and Eyeshadow Primer

AVON Sparkle Eyeshadow Stick - LATTE

AVON Big Color Eye Pencil Crayon Liner Eyeshadow SUNKISSED New Sealed!

Avon Sparkle Eyeshadow Stick pencil - Champagne

AVON Smooth Minerals Eye Shadow Pencil PEBBLE (HARD TO FIND) Sealed Eyeshadow

Avon Color Whirls 1988 Eye Pencil Violet Swirls

AVON Sparkle Eyeshadow Stick - LATTE

AVON Glimmer Shadow Liquid Eyeshadow - Crystal Lilac ~ New

new Avon Extra Lasting eyeshadow pencil - crystal taupe K201

AVON SMOOTH MINERALS EYE SHADOW PENCIL... LIMESTONE ....SEALED

new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon eyeshadow eye liner - lightening B01

Avon Eye Brightening Pencil HONEY BLUE Shadow & Liner NOS Like Big Color

CS Shiseido/Essentialist Eye Palette 04 Kaigan Street Waters 0.18 Oz (5.2 Ml)

Avon Big Color Dazzlers Sparkling Eye Pencil Cocoa Mauve

Best Selling

STILA - To You Eye Shadow Palette - Matte & Metallic - "HANGANG SUNSET" -

Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye - Rosegold

Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Colour in Cobblestone Retail

Julep Creme to Powder Eyeshadow Stick 101 Stone 0.04oz

Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick Hazelnut Matte

Bobbi Brown Retouching Wand Concealer Foundation Medium to Dark

Smashbox Always on GEL Liner Nymph 0.04 Ounce

AVON Glimmer Shadow ROSE GOLD + AVON Big Color LIGHTENING Eye Pencil Set