3-4 Years Retired Original Beanie Babies

Shop by Category

Beanie Babies-Original
- Retired
- Current

274,239 Results

Beanie Baby “MYSTIC” Unicorn Retired Rare Ty 93-94 Tag Errors (IRIDESCENT MANE)
(1)
$1,200.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+^ &0* ] w.?!9 |/ $QK 54S p o n s o r e d
Ty McDonalds Teenie Beanie 1999 Erin The Bear w/ Errors
(1)
$1,150.00
or Best Offer
$4.51 shipping
+^R 7 &O*Q ]T w.?!H| J/L $S p o n s o r e d
Ty Beanie Babies Platinum Edition Club Kit
$900.00
or Best Offer
$7.70 shipping
M1 5+^ &* ]4 w. ?!|LC / $G4S p o n s o r e d
Ty McDonalds Dinosaur Rex The Tyrannosaurus Rex Teenie Beanie Baby Rare BNIB
$794.63
or Best Offer
$46.96 shipping
K+^ 9 A&*1 9] Pw .?!HC |/H9 $S p o n s o r e d
Ty Beanie Babies New Face Violet/Purple Teddy Bear 4055 3rd Gen Hang 1st Tush
$425.00
or Best Offer
$7.00 shipping
+9^ &*E ] w1.A 3?!|/ $B WL
TY Beanie Baby - BATTY the Bat (TY-Dyed Version) 4.5'...NEW with Mint Tags
(53)
$11.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
69 watching
+^ &*RU ] wSV. ?!XN|/ M$Q
50 HEART SHAPED TAG PROTECTORS - FOR TY BEANIE BABIES / BUDDIES / TEENIES / KIDS
$18.99
$7.35 shipping
10 watching
+^ G&*U ]O P Q7 Kw.?!X|/ 2$
TY Beanie Baby - HALO the Angel Bear (8.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(27)
$10.89
Free shipping
+^CV &* K] 3 w.25?!| W/ $9
TY Beanie Baby - WEENIE the Dachshund Dog 7.5"...NEW with Mint Tags
(25)
$10.50
or Best Offer
Free shipping
6 watching
+2^ G&* ] Lw.N?!|/ 2$X
Original 1994 Ty Beanie Baby Quackers (Duck)
$25.00
or Best Offer
$4.84 shipping
+^Y N G&1 *W 3 ] wK.V?!|/ G7 $
Ty Beanie Baby Sarge the Dog DOB February 14, 2000 MWMT Free Shipping
(4)
$6.58
Was: $7.00was - US $7.00
Free shipping
+HV^ & 43* Y] 4 wGB .?I6!|/ $
TY Beanie Baby POOPSIE the Bear Plush (8 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(6)
$7.95
or Best Offer
$4.52 shipping
+^K &*6 ] Vw2.?!|/ $M3
TY Beanie Baby APRIL the Birthday Bear Plush (7.5 inch) MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(6)
$8.95
or Best Offer
$4.52 shipping
+^ F5 &O* X ] 1w.?S !|/ E$V
Rosalyne Beanie Baby - 1993
$200.00
or Best Offer
$4.84 shipping
V+^W &*S ]O Mw.?8! A|/ $D S p o n s o r e d
ty beanie baby Stretch 1997 with tag ERRORS Retired RARE
$1,000.00
or Best Offer
$4.84 shipping
+^Q T &SC P*2 ] JA w. RZ?!| / $S p o n s o r e d
TY Beanie Baby - PANAMA the Tree Frog (9.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(4)
$12.89
Free shipping
Only 1 left!
TC +^J 4&* R ]6 w.?P!E| B4 / $
TY Beanie Baby - GARCIA the Tie-Dyed Bear 1993 Plush Stuffed Animal
$20.00
$8.15 shipping
+^6 &M* ] w.? 0!Q |GW/ JR $
TY Beanie Baby - BONES the Dog (9 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(8)
$9.89
Free shipping
50 sold
+^ &* 7Q ]X L wKV .?H!|/M $
Vintage 2000 - TY Beanie Baby - 7 Inch Brown HERO the Father's Day Bear W/ Tie
(5)
$10.00
or Best Offer
$4.85 shipping
+^ &A*4 Q]7 BwI. L?!|C I/ $
TY Beanie Baby - NIP the Gold Cat (7.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(2)
$9.89
Free shipping
30 watching
C+4 Q^ &7 HB* ] 6 Lw .6?S !|/ $
Ty Beanie Baby Silver - MWMT (Cat Grey 1999)
(15)
$8.89
or Best Offer
Free shipping
Only 2 left
WB+ C^ &* ] w.2 ?!|H6/ $ 75
TY Beanie Baby - EGGBERT the Egg & Chick (6 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(9)
$9.89
Free shipping
61 sold
+^1R &* ] w.?! Z|D I3 UR/ YQ $
Beanie Baby Tracker - Rare - Errors
$875.00
or Best Offer
$4.84 shipping
H4 7+^H &* O] w0 H.Y ?7!|E/ $
2007 Ty Beanie Babies Jingle Beanies Sleddy The Penguin Mini Christmas Plush 4”
$10.00
or Best Offer
$4.85 shipping
+^ &* KS] D T KwM.?!| /JU 3$
TY Beanie Baby - PINKY the Pink Flamingo (10 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(22)
$9.89
Free shipping
42 sold
R+P^ &7N* ] w.I?7 !|3/ $Y
Ty Beanie Babies 13 Britannia Glory Erin Maple The Bear McDonalds Set 90's New
$8.94
$10.00 shipping
+^ &6* 8 ] w.P?2 !|3/F $ J
Ty Beanie Baby Tag Protectors Lot of 50 Plastic Heart Hang Tag Holders Set [New]
$24.99
Free shipping
Only 1 left!
E+K^ C &* S] I6 JCw.? !|L/ $
Ty Beanie Baby Stripes the Tiger DOB June 11, 1995 MWMT Free Shipping
$7.05
Was: $7.50was - US $7.50
Free shipping
+Q1^ &YE* UP K] 4w.?!| O7 / $
Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby Snip The Siamese Cat 1996 ( 💥RARE💥 )
$1,100.00
or Best Offer
$4.84 shipping
+N^ &*6 ] w.?LW! T|/ J$ S p o n s o r e d
Ty Beanie Baby GOATEE the Goat Plush 6.5 inch MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
(12)
$7.95
or Best Offer
$4.38 shipping
R+G^ &ZG G* ] Cw. ?!|/ $XP
Ty Beanie Buddy Snort the Bull Plush Toy - 4002
(23)
$285.00
or Best Offer
$8.85 shipping
+E^8 & * 85 ] UwT. 2H K?!|I / $
Vintage Beanie Baby Buddy Lot Bundle Fish, Lion, Caterpillar, Zebra, Seals Etc..
$34.99
$14.09 shipping
+XD^ S&*M ] w9.F? 7!2 |/N $
VTG Rare Ty Beanie Babies Tush Tag Heart PE Pellets Purple Princess Diana
$85.50
Was: $95.00was - US $95.00
or Best Offer
$6.95 shipping
+^ V1&* ]A w.?!U|/ Y V$ D9
Ty Punkies Skitters - Halloween Spider MWMT 2003
$6.00
$4.99 shipping
40 watching
2Z+^ C &* T] 0V w.AO?!|/ ZL $
TY Beanie Baby - SQUEALER the Pig 8"...NEW with Mint Tags
(13)
$9.85
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+^ 15 R&*Y ] w.W?Z!| PN/ $
TY Beanie Baby FORTUNE the Panda Bear Plush (8 inch) - MWMT's Stuffed Animal Toy
(11)
$7.95
or Best Offer
$4.75 shipping
+^1 C&* L] w.Y?! |/ $6W GX
Ty Beanie Baby - BLARN-e Irish Dog (Internet Exclusive) 6.5" New Plush Toy
$25.00
$8.15 shipping
+UH^ I&* U ] w.?0!|/ L$ ZL
TY Beanie Baby - HOPPITY the Pink Bunny (8 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(21)
$14.89
Free shipping
+JH^ & * ] w.?!I|/ Y Z$9 2
Ty Beanie Baby Fetch - MWMT (Dog Golden Lab 1997)
$375.00
or Best Offer
$4.84 shipping
5M+^ B2 &*LI ] w3.?!M RE| / $S p o n s o r e d
TY BEANIE BABIES BABY ORIGINAL BLIZZARD THE WHITE TIGER 96 PE RETIRED ERRORS NEW
$150.00
or Best Offer
$6.20 shipping
3+N ^Z &* 2] w5.?!|/O P $J
Ty Beanie Baby TRUMPET the Elephant (8.5 Inch) NEW MWMT Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
(9)
$11.89
or Best Offer
Free shipping
34 sold
+2^S XI&* ] Z w.?S!|/ $ HN
Ty Beanie Baby - SCUTTLE the Crab 30th Anniversary Limited Edition 2025 NEW
$9.90
or Best Offer
$5.99 shipping
31 sold
F+^ D& *4 ] w2. 0?!|5/ TM $
TY Beanie Baby - HOPE the Praying Bear (7 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(27)
$9.89
Free shipping
18 sold
+6^3 8 R&* XX] w.?!|V/R $
TY Beanie Baby - QUACKERS the Duck (5.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(13)
$9.89
Free shipping
16 sold
M+^ &* ] Yw .?A!K|/ $X2
TY Beanie Baby - LUCKY the Ladybug (5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(15)
$9.89
Free shipping
87 watching
+7^S &* ] w. ?8!|/Z $FK
TY Beanie Baby - SQUIDWARD TENTACLES 9.5 inch with Tag
(7)
$29.95
$4.57 shipping
+Y^ &V* ] ESw.?! |/ 73$ 9M
TY Beanie Baby - RIGHTY 2004 the Elephant (7 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy
(2)
$9.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
+^I &1* X]I w.51?! Q0|/ K $
Ty Gobbles the Turkey Beanie Baby 1996 Retired 4034 Excellent Condition
(39)
$225.00
or Best Offer
$4.84 shipping
+1^3 & H* 1] wXM R.?!A 3|/U $
Ty Beanie Baby MR POTATO PEPPA PIG UK Excl. NEW MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal Toy
(2)
$48.95
or Best Offer
$5.99 shipping
Only 2 left
+LR ^ &G3* PN] wZ.3 O?!Z| / $
Ty Original Beanie Babies My Little Pony Pinky Pie 5" Backpack Keychain
$8.00
Free shipping
42 watching
C2+^ & * 2] 4w .?!|A/H $
Vintage 1997 TY Beanie Buddy White Holiday Bear Plush In Knit Red Scarf Hat 13”
$15.00
or Best Offer
$6.22 shipping
S+^I &* ] E w.?!|/ U$ T6
Ty Beanie Baby 2.0 - McLUCKY the Irish Bear (Internet Exclusive) (8 inch) MWMTs
$39.90
or Best Offer
$5.99 shipping
2 watching
+Y^ &O 9* W ]Y wL. ?0J! |/ $
Garfield 9" Cat Plush Christmas Striped Elf Hat Scarf Ty Beanie Baby 2006 NWT
$15.95
or Best Offer
$6.20 shipping
+^5 B& 0*S ]JV wS.?!J|/ X$
TY Beanie Baby - AMBER the Gold Tabby Cat 7.5"...NEW with Mint Tags
(15)
$12.50
or Best Offer
Free shipping
9 watching
+U^I &* P7] 8wL LO. ?!|R/S $
Ty "Trumpet the Elephant" Beanie Baby 2000 - Retired
$150.00
or Best Offer
$4.84 shipping
5+^Y X &E* NW EJ ] 8w.?!N| / $
TY Beanie Buddy - PEANUT the Elephant (Royal Blue version) (15 inch) - MWMTs
(19)
$13.89
Free shipping
25 watching
+H^7 &*A5 TU ] wP.X?!|/ $
Ty Beanie Babies Scary The Witch Date Of Birth October 25, 2000 Tag Error
(8)
$9.00
or Best Offer
$4.57 shipping
+O^ Y& O* ]Y V2 6 H QNw.?!| / $
TY Beanie Baby - SWOOP the Pterodactyl 6"...NEW with Mint Tags
(15)
$9.85
or Best Offer
Free shipping
20 sold
+^ &Y* R] Bw.?0!|/ 0$J
McDONALDS TY Beanie Baby Britannia the Bear 🔥Rare With Tag Errors 1993 Retired
$1,200.00
or Best Offer
$4.51 shipping
+A^3 &* T]6 w. ?!G|Q/ $ZS p o n s o r e d
Ty Beanie Praying Babies, Selling as a set vintage all great condition
$50.00
or Best Offer
$9.39 shipping
LR +^ 1&* ]N w .?!|/S $O S p o n s o r e d

Best Selling

See All

Ty Beanie Babies Princess Bear Toy
(64)
$9.79 New
$3.00 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Halo the Angel Bear Toy
(27)
$6.39 New
$5.89 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Floppity 4th Generation Hang Tag 3rd Gen TT 1996
(15)
$8.89 New
$3.49 Used
Ty Beanie Baby Fleece Lamb Beanbag Plush Original Tag 1996 PE 4th Gen - 4125
(17)
$7.19 New
$2.00 Used
Ty Beanie Baby: Peace Bear 1996 - Multicolor
(66)
$6.34 New
$2.00 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Weenie The Dachshund Dog Toy
(25)
$6.72 New
$4.59 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Peanut The Elephant - Light Blue
(7)
$1.95 New
TY Beanie Baby – GOBBLES the Turkey (5.5 in)
(39)
$9.00 New
$8.28 Used

Top Rated

See All

Ty Beanie Baby: Peace Bear 1996 - Multicolor
(66)

100% agree - Durable
$6.34 New
$2.00 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Princess Bear Toy
(65)

96% agree - Durable
$9.79 New
$3.00 Used
TY Beanie Baby – GOBBLES the Turkey (5.5 in)
(39)

100% agree - Would recommend
$9.00 New
$8.28 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Halo the Angel Bear Toy
(27)

95% agree - Durable
$6.39 New
$5.89 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Weenie The Dachshund Dog Toy
(25)

100% agree - Would recommend
$6.72 New
$4.59 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Claude the Crab
(24)

100% agree - Would recommend
$7.05 New
$3.01 Used
Ty Beanie Buddy Snort the Bull Plush Toy - 4002
(23)

100% agree - Would recommend
$6.75 New
$3.00 Used
Ty Beanie Babies Pinky the Flamingo Plush Toy
(22)

100% agree - Would recommend
$6.65 New
$4.99 Used

Motors

Clothing & Accessories

Sporting goods

Electronics

Business & Industrial

Jewelry & Watches

Collectibles & Art

Home & garden

Other categories

3-4 Years Retired Original Beanie Babies

Shop by Category

274,239 Results

Beanie Baby “MYSTIC” Unicorn Retired Rare Ty 93-94 Tag Errors (IRIDESCENT MANE)

Ty McDonalds Teenie Beanie 1999 Erin The Bear w/ Errors

Ty Beanie Babies Platinum Edition Club Kit

Ty McDonalds Dinosaur Rex The Tyrannosaurus Rex Teenie Beanie Baby Rare BNIB

Ty Beanie Babies New Face Violet/Purple Teddy Bear 4055 3rd Gen Hang 1st Tush

TY Beanie Baby - BATTY the Bat (TY-Dyed Version) 4.5'...NEW with Mint Tags

50 HEART SHAPED TAG PROTECTORS - FOR TY BEANIE BABIES / BUDDIES / TEENIES / KIDS

TY Beanie Baby - HALO the Angel Bear (8.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

TY Beanie Baby - WEENIE the Dachshund Dog 7.5"...NEW with Mint Tags

Original 1994 Ty Beanie Baby Quackers (Duck)

Ty Beanie Baby Sarge the Dog DOB February 14, 2000 MWMT Free Shipping

TY Beanie Baby POOPSIE the Bear Plush (8 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

TY Beanie Baby APRIL the Birthday Bear Plush (7.5 inch) MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

Rosalyne Beanie Baby - 1993

ty beanie baby Stretch 1997 with tag ERRORS Retired RARE

TY Beanie Baby - PANAMA the Tree Frog (9.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

TY Beanie Baby - GARCIA the Tie-Dyed Bear 1993 Plush Stuffed Animal

TY Beanie Baby - BONES the Dog (9 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

Vintage 2000 - TY Beanie Baby - 7 Inch Brown HERO the Father's Day Bear W/ Tie

TY Beanie Baby - NIP the Gold Cat (7.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

Ty Beanie Baby Silver - MWMT (Cat Grey 1999)

TY Beanie Baby - EGGBERT the Egg & Chick (6 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

Beanie Baby Tracker - Rare - Errors

2007 Ty Beanie Babies Jingle Beanies Sleddy The Penguin Mini Christmas Plush 4”

TY Beanie Baby - PINKY the Pink Flamingo (10 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

Ty Beanie Babies 13 Britannia Glory Erin Maple The Bear McDonalds Set 90's New

Ty Beanie Baby Tag Protectors Lot of 50 Plastic Heart Hang Tag Holders Set [New]

Ty Beanie Baby Stripes the Tiger DOB June 11, 1995 MWMT Free Shipping

Rare Retired Ty Beanie Baby Snip The Siamese Cat 1996 ( 💥RARE💥 )

Ty Beanie Baby GOATEE the Goat Plush 6.5 inch MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

Ty Beanie Buddy Snort the Bull Plush Toy - 4002

Vintage Beanie Baby Buddy Lot Bundle Fish, Lion, Caterpillar, Zebra, Seals Etc..

VTG Rare Ty Beanie Babies Tush Tag Heart PE Pellets Purple Princess Diana

Ty Punkies Skitters - Halloween Spider MWMT 2003

TY Beanie Baby - SQUEALER the Pig 8"...NEW with Mint Tags

TY Beanie Baby FORTUNE the Panda Bear Plush (8 inch) - MWMT's Stuffed Animal Toy

Ty Beanie Baby - BLARN-e Irish Dog (Internet Exclusive) 6.5" New Plush Toy

TY Beanie Baby - HOPPITY the Pink Bunny (8 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

Ty Beanie Baby Fetch - MWMT (Dog Golden Lab 1997)

TY BEANIE BABIES BABY ORIGINAL BLIZZARD THE WHITE TIGER 96 PE RETIRED ERRORS NEW

Ty Beanie Baby TRUMPET the Elephant (8.5 Inch) NEW MWMT Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

Ty Beanie Baby - SCUTTLE the Crab 30th Anniversary Limited Edition 2025 NEW

TY Beanie Baby - HOPE the Praying Bear (7 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

TY Beanie Baby - QUACKERS the Duck (5.5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

TY Beanie Baby - LUCKY the Ladybug (5 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

TY Beanie Baby - SQUIDWARD TENTACLES 9.5 inch with Tag

TY Beanie Baby - RIGHTY 2004 the Elephant (7 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

Ty Gobbles the Turkey Beanie Baby 1996 Retired 4034 Excellent Condition

Ty Beanie Baby MR POTATO PEPPA PIG UK Excl. NEW MWMTs Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

Ty Original Beanie Babies My Little Pony Pinky Pie 5" Backpack Keychain

Vintage 1997 TY Beanie Buddy White Holiday Bear Plush In Knit Red Scarf Hat 13”

Ty Beanie Baby 2.0 - McLUCKY the Irish Bear (Internet Exclusive) (8 inch) MWMTs

Garfield 9" Cat Plush Christmas Striped Elf Hat Scarf Ty Beanie Baby 2006 NWT

TY Beanie Baby - AMBER the Gold Tabby Cat 7.5"...NEW with Mint Tags

Ty "Trumpet the Elephant" Beanie Baby 2000 - Retired

TY Beanie Buddy - PEANUT the Elephant (Royal Blue version) (15 inch) - MWMTs

Ty Beanie Babies Scary The Witch Date Of Birth October 25, 2000 Tag Error

TY Beanie Baby - SWOOP the Pterodactyl 6"...NEW with Mint Tags

McDONALDS TY Beanie Baby Britannia the Bear 🔥Rare With Tag Errors 1993 Retired

Ty Beanie Praying Babies, Selling as a set vintage all great condition

Best Selling

Ty Beanie Babies Princess Bear Toy

Ty Beanie Babies Halo the Angel Bear Toy

Ty Beanie Baby Floppity 4th Generation Hang Tag 3rd Gen TT 1996

Ty Beanie Baby Fleece Lamb Beanbag Plush Original Tag 1996 PE 4th Gen - 4125

Ty Beanie Baby: Peace Bear 1996 - Multicolor

Ty Beanie Babies Weenie The Dachshund Dog Toy

Ty Beanie Babies Peanut The Elephant - Light Blue